# Pizza in Wallingford

Windy City Pie

Name: Windy City Pie
Address: 5918 Phinney Ave N, Seattle, WA 98103, Seattle, WA, 98103, US
Telephone: (206) 486-4743
Price range: $$

Highly Reviewed

Pizza Wallingford $$ Open until 21:00

Kid-friendly Groups LGBTQ+ friendly

Composite Score

out of 100

From 1,437 reviews across multiple sources . Last verified May 25, 2026.

Freshness

Recently verified

Verified May 25, 2026

Why this place ranks

Windy City Pie is a pizza spot in Wallingford, mid-priced.

Quality

87 /100

Weight 75%. Review aggregation.

Trust + Editor

45 /100

Weight 10%. BBB, chamber, editor visit, freshness.

Find them on

Other places this business shows up online. We link out, you decide where to read more.

Facebook Instagram Foursquare

Reviews

Share what you thought. Reviews you submit count toward the User-Review portion of the Quality signal once our database is live.

Loading reviews...

Best for

casual cozy trendy fast service great beer selection great cocktails lunch dinner solo dining college students family-friendly groups lgbtq+ friendly transgender safespace

Hours

Monday: Closed
Tuesday: 16 – 21
Wednesday: 16 – 21
Thursday: 16 – 21
Friday: 12 – 22
Saturday: 12 – 22
Sunday: 12 – 21

Visit

Address

5918 Phinney Ave N, Seattle, WA 98103

Seattle, WA 98103
Phone
(206) 486-4743
Website
www.windycitypie.com

Get directions See menu / website

Good to know

Accepts reservations
Wheelchair accessible

Adds to Engagement (10% of composite)

Own this business? Claim your profile to edit hours, photos, and menu.

Composite rating derived from review aggregations across multiple sources, plus our editorial visit, community votes, and AI-derived sentiment from public neighborhood social signals referencing this business. Sources refreshed on independent schedules. We never republish third-party content verbatim — themed summaries are our own writing.